Hi,
For context, this is an issue I noticed on my karakeep instance, a FOSS bookmarking solution. I opened an issue there and was told the bug might be on readability's side. So I opened firefox, opened the webpage and indeed confirmed the bug is caused by readability.
Describe the Bug
I noticed that saving wikipedia pages to karakeep would sometimes miss the section headers.
I finally figured out how to reproduce this: headers that are only a single world are always removed whereas those that span over multiple words are kept.
This might happen outside of wikipedia too but I can't know what I'm missing.
Steps to Reproduce
- On firefox, go to German tank problem.
- Notice its table of content and how some sections are single words like
Suppositions while others are over multiple words like Historical example of the problem.
- Open readability on that page
- Search each of the table of content section headers. Presents are
Historical example of the problem, Frequentist analysis and Bayesian Analysis. Also See also, Further reading and External links. Missing are: Suppositions, Example, Countermeasures, Notes and References.
- Notice that the common feature of the missing title is the fact that they are single words.
Expected Behaviour
All headers should be kept.
Screenshots or Additional Context
Here is the table of content:
And here notice the missing Suppositions section header:
But other section headers do exist:
Device Details
No response
Exact Firefox Version
144.0
Hi,
For context, this is an issue I noticed on my karakeep instance, a FOSS bookmarking solution. I opened an issue there and was told the bug might be on readability's side. So I opened firefox, opened the webpage and indeed confirmed the bug is caused by readability.
Describe the Bug
I noticed that saving wikipedia pages to karakeep would sometimes miss the section headers.
I finally figured out how to reproduce this: headers that are only a single world are always removed whereas those that span over multiple words are kept.
This might happen outside of wikipedia too but I can't know what I'm missing.
Steps to Reproduce
Suppositionswhile others are over multiple words likeHistorical example of the problem.Historical example of the problem,Frequentist analysisandBayesian Analysis. AlsoSee also,Further readingandExternal links. Missing are:Suppositions,Example,Countermeasures,NotesandReferences.Expected Behaviour
All headers should be kept.
Screenshots or Additional Context
Here is the table of content:
And here notice the missing
Suppositionssection header:But other section headers do exist:
Device Details
No response
Exact Firefox Version
144.0