UCI import with 15min timestep

[trees4me]

Hi,
I have a UCI file that runs at 15min timestep. A couple issues have come up running the import checks, but I'm still unable to reproduce HSPF results.

Issues:

1. external sources evap record is 15-min with a 0.75 multiplier in HSPF. The MFACTOR comes into HSP2 ok, but needs to be divided by 96 (=4*24). After revising this MFACTOR the IMPLND and portions of the PERLND are ok.

2. The PERLND in HSP2 are not reproducing HSPF results. I've traced the source to the groundwater storage bin (AGWS/AGWO). Everything above that is nearly identical. The AGWI is nearly identical for HSP2 vs HSPF.
   

However, the AGWO, AGWS, and GWVS all vary between HSP2 and HSPF. I checked all the PERLND parameters and states and they are the same. Evap is off on the groundwater bin (AGWET=BASET=0).

Trying to figure out what to try next. KGW appears to be 0 (AGWRC=0.997, DELT60=0.25 for 15min), and perhaps HSP2 is treating this case differently than HSPF? Is something else different about the groundwater routine? Perhaps the 15-min time step may be an issue here as it was with item 1.
Any ideas are appreciated.
Thanks.

[JasonLoveRespec]

Thanks for the detailed explanation of the issue. We will look into and get back to you with any information. JASON LOVE, P.E. Senior Vice President 605.394.6512 office // 605.484.2380 cell

…

________________________________ From: trees4me <notifications@github.com> Sent: Tuesday, January 29, 2019 3:06 AM To: respec/HSPsquared Cc: Subscribed Subject: [respec/HSPsquared] UCI import with 15min timestep (#22) Hi, I have a UCI file that runs at 15min timestep. A couple issues have come up running the import checks, but I'm still unable to reproduce HSPF results. Issues: 1. external sources evap record is 15-min with a 0.75 multiplier in HSPF. The MFACTOR comes into HSP2 ok, but needs to be divided by 96 (=4*24). After revising this MFACTOR the IMPLND and portions of the PERLND are ok. 2. The PERLND in HSP2 are not reproducing HSPF results. I've traced the source to the groundwater storage bin (AGWS/AGWO). Everything above that is nearly identical. The AGWI is nearly identical for HSP2 vs HSPF. [perlnd_p211_pwater_agwi]<https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/35086910/51899915-df36eb00-2368-11e9-96d7-8dbe15fb0fd0.png> However, the AGWO, AGWS, and GWVS all vary between HSP2 and HSPF. I checked all the PERLND parameters and states and they are the same. Evap is off on the groundwater bin (AGWET=BASET=0). [perlnd_p211_pwater_agwo]<https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/35086910/51900254-b4996200-2369-11e9-8348-5c454e6ec547.png> [perlnd_p211_pwater_agws]<https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/35086910/51900255-b4996200-2369-11e9-8457-83adb44484c1.png> Trying to figure out what to try next. KGW appears to be 0 (AGWRC=0.997, DELT60=0.25 for 15min), and perhaps HSP2 is treating this case differently than HSPF? Is something else different about the groundwater routine? Perhaps the 15-min time step may be an issue here as it was with item 1. Any ideas are appreciated. Thanks. — You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub<#22>, or mute the thread<https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AcYK3oh45LvmSJamLPLAMk3yYcWxzjU9ks5vIB03gaJpZM4aXs2E>. Confidentiality Notice: This E-mail and any attachments is covered by the Electronic Communications Privacy Act, 18 U.S.C. & 2510-2524, is confidential and may be legally privileged. If you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any retention, dissemination, or copying of this communication is strictly prohibited. Please reply to the sender that you have received the message in error, and permanently delete the original and destroy any copy, including printed copies of this email and any attachments thereto.

[trees4me]

I did a quick test with DELT=60min and the perlnds/implnds are ok. It's appears to be an issue related to the 15min time step, where KGW trends to 0. At 60min DELT the KGW value is non-0.

Thanks
-Pat

perlnd comparison table HSP2 (60min) vs HSPF (15min), reasonable monthly results.

	Max Diff	Sum of HSPF	Sum of HSP2	%diff of Sum	abs(%diff of Sum)
274	1.36	547.93	548.01	-0.01	0.01
241	1.45	534.70	534.28	0.08	0.08
242	1.45	533.44	533.02	0.08	0.08
243	1.45	532.21	531.77	0.08	0.08
244	1.45	530.87	530.42	0.08	0.08
273	1.30	514.84	514.28	0.11	0.11
231	1.43	505.02	504.26	0.15	0.15
233	1.40	500.49	499.73	0.15	0.15
234	1.41	499.73	498.96	0.15	0.15
232	1.43	504.22	503.44	0.15	0.15
284	1.36	435.23	434.46	0.18	0.18
211	1.03	401.23	400.39	0.21	0.21
272	1.23	460.03	458.95	0.23	0.23
221	1.33	452.18	451.07	0.24	0.24
212	1.12	417.38	416.35	0.25	0.25
222	1.36	462.33	461.17	0.25	0.25
223	1.32	454.83	453.68	0.25	0.25
224	1.33	454.92	453.76	0.25	0.25
271	1.12	415.12	414.07	0.25	0.25
213	1.28	441.69	440.51	0.27	0.27
214	1.36	464.83	463.58	0.27	0.27
283	1.24	401.24	400.12	0.28	0.28
282	1.10	382.03	380.94	0.29	0.29
285	1.10	382.03	380.94	0.29	0.29
281	1.13	384.55	383.40	0.30	0.30

[aufdenkampe]

@trees4me, although you posted this issue 2 years ago, it might be of interest that there's been renewed work on this in the last 6-9 months, as tracked with:

• Improve readUCI & readWDM for a broader range of valid files #40
• Merge develop_readWDM into develop to read time series by block & group LimnoTech/HSPsquared#35
• Merge develop_readWDM into develop to read time series by block & group LimnoTech/HSPsquared#37

If you are still using this, or interested in helping us test, some of the more recent updates discussed there are still on the develop branch.

[aufdenkampe]

Closing this issue as it's now been implemented with closing of #40.